My Quince Review After 3 Years: Is Quince Good Quality?

Quince Review woman in silk maxi skirt

In this Article

Share

Disclosure: Some links on this page are affiliate links, so I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Quince gifted me the silk maxi skirt and discounted the wool coat. I paid for everything else myself. Neither changed what I have to say about the cashmere.

I started buying Quince in 2023, after one too many ads for cashmere at a price that made me look twice. Three years and nine pieces later, I have a clearer answer than the ads gave me.

Some of it has earned a permanent spot in my closet. Some of it now shares a shelf with a sweater shaver. Here’s which is which, with what I paid, how long I’ve worn it, and how it looks today.

Before you buy: I check fiber content, seams and fabric weight on every piece. Here's how to tell if clothing is good quality, the same checks I used on my Quince pieces. Or see every brand I've reviewed.

The Bottom Line: What I’d Buy Again After 3 Years

Buy Quince for silk, outerwear and cotton basics. Skip the cashmere, which is the one category the brand is famous for.

PieceWhat I paidVerdict
Silk Maxi Skirt$85 (gifted)Buy again
Washable Silk Drawstring Wide-Leg Pants$92Buy, but not for travel
Italian Wool Tailored Coat$200 (discounted)Buy again
Organic Cotton Trench Coat$130Buy, one month in
Micro-Rib Turtleneck$25Buy again
Cotton T-ShirtsBought as a 3-packBuy again
Simona Leather Continental Wallet$52Buy again
Mongolian Cashmere Structured Cardigan$160Skip, buy secondhand
Mongolian Cashmere Boatneck Sweater$80Skip

Quince is best for:

  • Building a wardrobe of foundational staples in natural fibers on a real budget.
  • Washable silk. This is where the price-to-quality math works hardest in your favor.

Quince may not be for:

  • Anyone hoping $160 buys cashmere that looks new in five years.
  • Fashion-forward shoppers. The designs lean minimal, so look elsewhere for statement pieces.

What is Quince?

Quince Womens affordable cashmere Sweaters

Quince is part of a growing wave of direct-to-consumer brands that are changing the game by offering high-quality pieces without the traditional retail markup. By cutting out the middleman, Quince delivers clothing, accessories, and home goods at prices that are often significantly lower than traditional retail. 

Although the brand is relatively new, founded in San Francisco in 2018, it’s quickly gaining attention (and, more importantly, market share) as shoppers seek quality pieces that don’t involve jaw-dropping price tags.

My Full Quince Clothing Review: Fabric, Fit, & Quality

Below is every piece I own, grouped by fabric, with what I paid, when I bought it, and how it has held up.

Quince Silk Review

Quince Review woman in silk maxi skirt

Quince’s silk is the best reason to shop there. Both pieces I own are machine-washable mulberry silk, and the fabric has held up on each. For a deeper look, I put my Quince pieces side by side with my dry-clean Reformation silk in my washable silk quality review.

The Silk Maxi Skirt ($85, gifted)

Fit: It’s cut on the bias, so it skims the body rather than clinging to it. At 5’3 it hits mid-ankle, which gives it a floating effect when I walk. I’ve worn it to dinners and parties, and it’s the piece I get asked about most.

Fabric: 100% mulberry silk at 19 momme, a good weight for a skirt: enough body to drape, not so light that it clings. It goes in the washing machine, which most silk skirts at any price can’t.

Quality: Turn it inside out and the seams are French seams, with the raw edges fully enclosed. That’s a slow, finicky finish you usually see on designer pieces at several times the price.

Verdict: Buy again. Shop the Silk Maxi Skirt here.

The Washable Silk Drawstring Wide-Leg Pants ($92, Nov 2025)

Woman wearing champagne Quince washable silk drawstring wide-leg pants with a cream knit cardigan

Fit and feel: These are the most comfortable pants I own that still look like I made an effort. The drawstring waist means no fighting a zipper, and the wide leg moves with you.

Styling: They pair with almost anything. I wear them with a fitted knit and flats, and they read polished without trying.

The catch: They wrinkle if you look at them. I steam them every single time I wear them, which rules them out for travel. If a garment has to survive a suitcase, look elsewhere.

Verdict: Buy, as long as you own a steamer and don’t plan to pack them. Shop Quince silk here.

Looking for quality clothing at an accessible price point? These affordable clothing brands are a must-see.

Quince Cashmere Review: Where My Verdict Changed

Quince cashmere is the reason most people find the brand, and it’s the category I’d now tell you to skip. Both of my sweaters pilled early.

The Mongolian Cashmere Structured Cardigan ($160, Feb 2025)

woman in Quince mongolian cashmere cardigan

Fit: True to size. I wear my usual small, and it skims the body without clinging. It looks best fully buttoned, where the cut nips in at the waist.

Construction: Inside out, it’s fully fashioned, meaning each panel was knitted to shape and linked rather than cut and sewn. The seams are clean and the buttons are on securely. On construction alone, it earns its price.

woman in cashmere cardigan, black pants, and red flats

How it held up: It started pilling after a handful of washes. In fairness, the label says hand wash only, and I used the delicate cycle. I paid for that shortcut. I now de-pill it often enough that the sweater shaver lives in my closet.

The shape has held. The surface hasn’t.

The Mongolian Cashmere Boatneck Sweater ($80, fall 2024)

Soft, and that’s where the good news ends. The knit isn’t dense enough, and it pilled early on. A looser knit leaves more fiber exposed to friction, which is exactly what makes cashmere snag and pill. I wouldn’t buy it again.

My verdict on Quince cashmere

“100% cashmere” on a label tells you the fiber. It doesn’t tell you the quality. Whether a sweater pills in a season or lasts a decade comes down to fiber length and knit density, and neither is printed on the tag. I go deeper on what to check in my guide to telling if clothing is good quality.

If you buy Quince cashmere, choose the thicker pieces and actually hand wash them. If you want cashmere that lasts, look secondhand. For around what this cardigan cost new, you can find denser knits from brands that never cut those corners.

Quince Outerwear Review: Wool and Trench Coats

Both coats earned their price. Each cuts one corner on the lining, and you can live with it.

The Italian Wool Tailored Coat ($200, discounted by Quince, Oct 2025)

Woman in winter coat during snow

Fit: As a petite, I usually swim in coats. The XS fits my 5’3 frame properly: the sleeves end at my wrist and the waist actually cinches. It got me through a Chicago winter without a puffer.

Fabric: 80% Italian wool, 20% nylon. I’ll allow the nylon in a coat, since it adds structure and helps the wool hold up to years of wear. The outer fabric feels substantial in the hand.

Quality: Three signs of real construction. The sleeves are set in, which gives a tailored line through the shoulder. The lining is bagged, attached cleanly at the hem. And the buttons are genuine horn, with working buttons at the cuffs.

Woman in long brown wool coat

Where Quince saved money: The lining is 55% polyester and 45% viscose, and I wish it breathed better. The exterior pockets are also fake, a cruel detail for anyone with perpetually cold hands. Bring gloves.

Verdict: Buy again. Shop the Italian Wool Tailored Coat here.

The Organic Cotton Trench Coat ($130, Sept 2026)

Woman wearing an olive Quince organic cotton trench coat over a white turtleneck and denim skirt

Fabric: 98% organic cotton, 2% spandex. Organic cotton is hard to find at this price, and the spandex gives it just enough give to move in. It’s water resistant, with an adjustable belt.

Close-up of the Quince trench coat's horn-look buttons, storm flap and buckled cuff strap

Fit and structure: It has enough structure to hold its shape, so it works over most of my fall outfits. The double-breasted front, storm flap and buckled cuff straps are all there.

The catch: It’s lined in polyester. I wish the organic cotton extended to the lining too.

How it’s wearing: I’ve only had it a month, so this is an early read. It’s become my default for the stretch of fall when it’s too cold for no coat and too early for a heavy one. I’ll update this after a full season.

Verdict: Buy, with the caveat that it’s one month in. Shop Quince outerwear here.

Quince Cotton Basics Review

The basics are unglamorous, and they’re some of the best value in the store. Both have held up.

The Micro-Rib Turtleneck ($25)

Fit: Fitted without being restrictive, which is exactly what a layering turtleneck should do. Size small, true to size.

Fabric: 97% organic cotton, 3% spandex, at $25. Organic cotton usually costs more than this, so I bought a few.

Quality: The seams are finished with a dense, even serged stitch, the right choice for a stretchy knit. The hem is coverstitched, so it stretches without popping threads.

Verdict: Buy again. Shop the Micro-Rib Turtleneck here.

The Cotton T-Shirts (3-pack)

woman in black Quince fitted t-shirt

Fit: A true slim fit, more sculpted than an Everlane boxy tee. If you want relaxed, skip it. Size small, true to size.

Fabric: Organic cotton with a touch of spandex, in a micro-rib that reads a little more polished than flat jersey.

Quality spotting tip: On a well-made tee, the neckband is a separate piece with a clean interior stitch, as it is here. That’s what stops the neckline from stretching into bacon-neck after a dozen washes.

Verdict: Buy again. Shop the Cotton T-Shirts here.

Quince Leather Review

The Simona Leather Continental Wallet ($52)

Material: 100% top-grain Italian leather in a pebbled finish. Quince’s tanneries are Leather Working Group certified.

Function: A full-size zip-around with 12 card slots, bill pockets and a center zip compartment. It suits a tote or a medium bag. I’ve since moved to smaller bags, so it’s no longer my everyday wallet.

How it held up: After nearly three years, it shows minimal wear and the leather is still soft.

Verdict: Buy again, if you carry a bag big enough for it. Shop the Simona Wallet here.

Is Quince Good Quality?

Quince Clothing homepage showing bags, tops, and accessories

Yes, in silk, cotton, wool and leather. No, in the cashmere it built its name on. After three years and nine pieces, seven earned their price and two pilled.

The pattern is consistent. Where Quince uses a dense, structured fabric, the construction holds up and the price is fair. Where it competes on price in a fiber whose quality lives in the knit, it shows. That’s why the thin $80 boatneck went first.

Understanding Quince Sizing

Quince runs true to size. I wear a small in tops and knits and an XS in the wool coat at 5’3. Most product pages carry fit notes (fitted, relaxed or oversized), and I’ve found them reliable. If you’re petite, check the length measurement before anything else.

How Quince Compares to Similar Brands

trousers summer outfit
BrandKnown forCompared with Quince
EverlaneOnce known for transparent pricing; Shein bought a majority stake in 2026Quince is now the steadier pick for natural-fiber basics
Cuyana“Fewer, better things” leather and silkCuyana costs more; Quince is the budget route to similar minimal staples
NaadamTraceable, sustainably sourced cashmereSimilar price tier. Given how my Quince cashmere wore, compare knit density in hand before choosing either
Jenni KayneCalifornia-casual knits at premium pricesQuince costs a fraction. For cashmere at that budget, secondhand Jenni Kayne may be the better buy

For more options, see 12 Quality Brands Like Quince. Before you buy, check my Quince discount code and sale calendar.

Quince FAQs

Let’s round out this Quince review with answers to common questions about the brand. 

Yes. I’ve bought from Quince for three years, and orders, sizing and returns have been straightforward. The brand has also gifted and discounted pieces to me, which I’ve disclosed at the top of this review.

Quince sells direct to you and works with factories directly, which cuts out the retail markup. The tradeoff shows up in small places: polyester linings, false pockets, and thinner knits on some sweaters.

Partly. Good On You rates Quince “Not Good Enough,” citing limited transparency on labor and supply chain. In its favor, much of the range uses organic cotton, mulberry silk and recycled materials, and the best pieces last. A coat you wear for years does more good than a cheaper one you replace.

Mine did. Both sweaters pilled within a handful of washes, and the thinner one pilled first. Hand washing slows it down. A denser knit is the better fix.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Next Articles