VIVAIA Shoes Review: Two Aria 5° Flats After Almost Two Years

Woman in Fair Isle sweater wearing red VIVAIA flats outdoors

In this Article

Share

Back in 2024, I was building out a list of closet must-haves. In the essential shoe column of my spreadsheet (yes, wardrobe building is a detailed process for me), I typed three words: pointed ballet flats.

I knew my shoe collection was missing this versatile piece. But I didn’t want just any flats. They had to be flattering. They had to be durable. And since I walk at least 8,000 steps a day, they had to be comfortable.

It wasn’t long before I came across VIVAIA and its Aria 5° flats in ruby red. Adorable and machine washable? Okay, add to cart. Almost two years later, I’ve worn that red pair through multiple seasons and countries.

They still get compliments, and I’ve since added a neutral pair, bought secondhand on ThredUp.

Here’s my full VIVAIA shoes review, covering how both pairs have held up and whether I’d buy them again.

I bought both pairs myself. This post contains affiliate links, so I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Before you buy

I check every pair of shoes against the same quality signs I use for clothing. See my guide to how to tell if clothing is good quality, or browse more pairs I've tested in my shoe guide.

Are VIVAIA Shoes Good? What You Need to Know

Red VIVAIA flats walking down wooden stairs on a grassy trail

  • They’re comfortable for real walking. I wear mine on 8,000-step city days and long travel days. My feet needed a couple of wears to settle in.
  • The red pair has held up for 21 months. The only real wear is a little fuzz at the very tip of the toe.
  • The lighter almond pair is wearing faster. Its knit is thinner, and one insole is peeling at the heel.
  • Machine washing works. Cold water, delicate cycle, air dry. The red dye has never run on me.
  • They aren’t waterproof. A rainy day in Turin soaked them through, and they took a full day to dry.
  • I’d buy them again. If you want them to last, choose a thicker knit. 
 Ruby red (new)Almond (secondhand)
Price I paid$140 on Amazon, February 2025$76 on ThredUp, May 2025
ComfortComfortable after one wear, still cushionedComfortable, but the insoles have flattened
DurabilityLight fuzz at the toe tip after 21 monthsFraying toe tips and a peeling insole after 18 months
LooksStill gets complimentsClean shape, shows dirt quickly
WashingWashes clean, no dye transferWashes fine

A Review of Two VIVAIA Flats I Own

Aria 5° in ruby red, $140 new on Amazon

Black top, dark jeans and red VIVAIA flats in a mirror selfie

I bought these in February 2025 for $140 on Amazon, in a size 39. VIVAIA calls this pointed-toe ballet flat the Aria 5°, after a 5-degree angle the brand builds into the toe to give your toes more room inside a pointed shape. It sounds like a weather report, but the angle is the reason a pointed flat can feel this easy.

From spring through summer, I wore them three to four times a week, all over Chicago.

Aria 5° in almond, $76 secondhand on ThredUp

Almond two-tone VIVAIA Aria 5 flats, side view

In May 2025 I found a second pair on ThredUp, listed in excellent condition, for $76. You already know I was pumped. Same shoe, in an almond knit with a tan trim, and they arrived looking unworn. It also turned into a good test of whether VIVAIA shoes are worth buying secondhand. More on that below.

Are VIVAIA Shoes Comfortable for Walking?

Woman in gingham top and white shorts wearing red VIVAIA Aria 5 pointed-toe flats

Yes, once your toes get acquainted. The first time I wore the red pair, my fourth and pinky toes felt squished, and I wondered if I’d ordered them too small. The rest of the shoe fit well, so I kept them on. After a short while my toes settled and spread out, and I haven’t had that feeling since.

The insole is where the comfort comes from. It has a soft pad underfoot that I noticed the first time I tried them on, and on the red pair it still feels cushioned after almost two years.

The real test was a travel day. Most recently I wore the red pair on an overnight flight from Chicago to Italy, then on the train into Rome. My feet felt as good stepping off that train as they did at the gate in Chicago.

For a full day of city walking, they’ve earned their spot by my door.

How VIVAIA Shoes Hold Up After Almost Two Years

The red pair has a little fuzz at the toe

After 21 months of regular wear, the main sign of wear on the red pair sits at the very tip of the toe. A couple of months ago I noticed slight fuzzing there, the kind you only see up close. The knit still holds its shape, and the tread on the soles still looks crisp.

The almond pair is wearing faster

Almond VIVAIA flats showing fraying at the toe tips

The almond pair is a thinner knit. I can see the outline of my toes through the top, and I wish it were slightly thicker. It’s fine for spring and summer, but the toe tips are fraying, and the lighter pair has less cushioning left in it.

 Almond VIVAIA shoes being worn with white pants

When I look at the insoles, the difference is obvious. One has started peeling at the heel and both have flattened, while the red insoles are still going strong.

One honest caveat. I bought these secondhand, so some of that insole wear could predate me. The thinner knit, though, is something I can see and feel.

What I’d do differently

Pick a darker, denser color. Darker knits hide dirt at the toe, and on my two pairs the darker knit is also the sturdier one. The insoles are removable, so if the cushioning flattens you can swap in a new pair of insoles instead of replacing the shoes.

Are VIVAIA Shoes Well Made? What I Found Up Close

Rubber outsole of a VIVAIA Aria 5 flat, size 39

I judge shoes the same way I judge clothes, by looking at how they’re built before I trust how they feel. My full method is in my guide to how to tell if clothing is good quality. 

Here’s what the Aria 5° shows when you take it apart a little.

  • The upper is a recycled knit. VIVAIA says each pair is made from six recycled plastic bottles. The knit stretches to your foot, which is why the pointed toe stopped pinching after my first wear.
  • The insole lifts out. Underneath, the knit upper is stitched to a footbed, and the label on mine says made in China.
  • The outsole is glued on. I can’t see any stitching where the rubber meets the knit. That’s standard for knit flats, and it means these can’t be resoled. 
  • The sole is thin rubber with tread at the heel and ball. After 21 months on Chicago sidewalks, the tread on my red pair still looks crisp.

Red VIVAIA Aria 5 knit ballet flats, side view

This isn’t luxury construction, and at this price I wouldn’t expect it to be. What matters is that the parts that wear first, the knit at the toe and the insole, have held up on the red pair, and the insole can be replaced.

I keep a shorter version of my quality checklist on my phone for shopping trips. It's five questions on one page, and it's all yours.

Get the 5-Point Checklist

Can You Machine Wash VIVAIA Shoes? 

Red VIVAIA flats toe before and after machine washing

Yes, and it’s a big part of why these get so much wear. Compared to my leather loafers or suede boots, my VIVAIA shoes are low maintenance. They do show dirt, especially at the very tips of the toes after a day of walking.

How to wash VIVAIA shoes

  1. Loosen the dirt on the toe tips with a soft toothbrush.
  2. Wash them on a cold, delicate cycle.
  3. Air dry. In warm months I leave them on my roof. In winter they dry indoors and take eight hours or more.

I wash them every three to four months, or every two months if I’m traveling or wearing them a lot. It’s the closest thing to a spa day my shoes get. VIVAIA warns that its ruby red dye can transfer, but mine have never run, in the wash or soaking wet in the rain.

Are VIVAIA Shoes Waterproof? What Happened in Turin

Red VIVAIA flats on stone pavement in Turin

No. Most recently I wore my ruby red flats in Italy, on the train from Rome to Turin. They were perfectly comfortable as I rolled my behemoth suitcase along Turin’s cobblestone streets.

Then the November rain came. It collected in puddles all over the street and dripped down over the sides of my umbrella. I arrived at the hotel dry, but my flats were soaking wet and my feet were frigid.

So I took the insoles out and let everything dry on a towel in the hotel bathroom. Overnight I moved them out to the balcony. In the morning they were better, but still damp. They weren’t fully dry until I checked them after dinner that evening.

They can handle a drizzle. A day of puddles is too much. They won’t replace your rain boots or sturdier shoes in wet weather. VIVAIA does sell a water-repellent version of the Aria 5°, which I haven’t tried. If you walk in the rain often, that’s the version I’d look at.

VIVAIA Sizing and Fit

Do VIVAIA shoes run true to size?

For me, yes. I usually wear a US 8, and both of my pairs are a 39. If you’re wondering whether VIVAIA shoes run small, mine didn’t.

What if you have wide feet?

VIVAIA doesn’t make a separate wide-width Aria 5°. Instead, the brand angles the toe inward to give your toes more room, and markets the regular Aria 5° for wide feet. My feet lean slightly wide, and my smaller toes needed one wear to adjust. If your feet are wider than mine, check VIVAIA’s size guide before you order.

Returns

VIVAIA offers 30-day returns, but shoes need to come back unworn, so try them on indoors on a clean floor or rug. Final Sale pairs can’t be returned at all, which is worth checking before a sale pair goes in your cart.

New vs. Secondhand: Is a $76 ThredUp Pair Worth It?

Almond VIVAIA Aria 5 flats in a ThredUp shipping box

I paid $140 for my red pair new and $76 for the almond pair on ThredUp, about half the price for the same shoe. The secondhand pair arrived looking unworn.

The catch is that it’s the pair wearing out first. I can’t say for sure whether that comes from the thinner almond knit or from wear before it reached me. If you buy VIVAIA secondhand, look closely at the listing photos of the toe tips and insoles, and favor darker colors.

How I Style VIVAIA Flats

Cream vest, wide-leg jeans and almond VIVAIA flats

The pointed toe is what makes these look polished. They lengthen the line of a wide-leg jean, dress up a simple vest, and the red pair adds a pop of color to an otherwise neutral outfit.

Burgundy mini dress with almond VIVAIA flats

The knit is flexible enough to fold into a suitcase without taking up much room, which is why at least one pair comes on almost every trip.

Is VIVAIA Legit?

Yes. VIVAIA was founded in 2020 and sells through its own site and on Amazon, where I bought my first pair.

Where are VIVAIA shoes made?

The label on my pair says made in China. VIVAIA doesn’t name its factories, and says it works with global suppliers.

Who Should Buy VIVAIA Shoes, and Who Should Skip Them

Buy them if you walk a lot, want a pointed flat that looks polished with jeans and dresses, and like shoes you can throw in the wash. They’re a good travel shoe for flights, trains and long days on foot.

Skip them if you need a shoe for wet weather, or you want something you can resole and keep for a decade. 

I’d buy them again. I’m even considering VIVAIA’s boots this season.

Shop the VIVAIA Aria 5°

VIVAIA Shoes FAQs

Are VIVAIA shoes good for walking?

For city walking, yes. I wear mine on 8,000-step days and travel days. They’re flats with a thin sole, and they don’t handle heavy rain.

Do VIVAIA flats stretch out?

Not that I’ve noticed. After almost two years, my red pair still holds its shape.

Do VIVAIA shoes pill?

Lightly, at the toe. My Aria 5s have slight fuzzing at the tip after 21 months. 

Can you buy VIVAIA secondhand?

Yes. I bought my almond pair on ThredUp for $76. Check the listing photos for wear at the toe tips and insoles before you buy.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Next Articles